レビューはレビュアーの個人的な意見であるため、特定の記載内容を検証することはありません。ただし、ビジネス上の取引が行われたことを確認できた場合、レビューに「確認済み」のラベルを付ける場合があります。詳細はこちら

プラットホームの健全性を維持するため、当社のプラットフォーム上のすべてのレビューは、確認済みか否かにかかわらず、年中無休で稼働する自動ソフトウェアによって審査されています。このテクノロジーは、本当の経験に基づいていないレビューなど、ガイドラインに違反するコンテンツを特定し、削除するよう設計されています。ただし、すべてを検知できるわけではありませんので、お気づきの点がございましたら、どうぞお知らせください。詳細はこちら

レビュアーのコメントを見てみましょう

5つ星のうち5の評価

I love Magic Nothing!! Been following the IG account for a long time and just tried the new site for playlisting and hiring somebody to help market my new single. It's super easy to use (though... もっと見る

企業が回答しました

5つ星のうち1の評価

I found Magic Nothing through Instagram meta ads. His guides are however basically overpriced and open sourced information that you can distill easily in a matter of 1-2 hours. The website itself from... もっと見る

企業が回答しました

5つ星のうち5の評価

I’ve tried a lot of playlist portals & this one has been the best so far. It is a little more expensive then other ones like Submithub but I have found the playlists are of higher quality, have real l... もっと見る

企業が回答しました

5つ星のうち5の評価

Been using this platform both as a curator and artist and I absolutely love it. Got placed on a ton of playlists and got a lot of streams from those playlists as well. Even had a few people DM me per... もっと見る

企業が回答しました

企業情報

  1. 音楽のマネジメント・プロモート

当該企業による記述

Music marketing doesn't have to suck!!!


連絡先

4.1

ほぼ満足

TrustScore 5段階評価の4

27件のレビュー

5つ星
4つ星
3つ星
2つ星
1つ星

最近のレビュー依頼の記録はありません

この企業は最近、顧客にレビューを依頼していないため、レビューが全体の意見を反映していない可能性があります。

ネガティブなレビューの 100%に回答しています

通常2週間以内に回答

この企業のTrustpilot 利用方法

レビューや評価の取得方法、スコアリング、モデレーションのプロセスについて確認する。

4.1

すべてのレビュー

(27)

過去12か月のレビュー数: 27件

レビューを書く
Trustpilot に参加している企業は、インセンティブを提供したり、レビューを非表示にするためにお金を払ったりすることは許可されていません。レビューはレビュアーの個人的な意見で、Trustpilot のものではありません。詳細はこちら

5つ星のうち5の評価

I love Magic Nothing!

I love Magic Nothing!! Been following the IG account for a long time and just tried the new site for playlisting and hiring somebody to help market my new single. It's super easy to use (though I did have to do a little digging to find good playlists) and I got a couple placements and some good feedback and also hired a marketer and got some solid results.

I will say some curators leave better reviews than others, but it's all good. Maybe that's my one criticism

For the marketer, they've been doing excellent work so far. I already broke a couple thousand streams and it took basically no effort from me. I like that you can communicate with them directly and tell them exactly what you're looking for. I don't have time to run ads myself so this is super helpful for me

Thanks!!

2026年8月28日
自発的なレビュー
Magicnothing ロゴ

Magicnothing からの回答

Thanks Adam! Glad you're having a positive experience :)

-Zack

5つ星のうち1の評価

I found Magic Nothing through Instagram…

I found Magic Nothing through Instagram meta ads. His guides are however basically overpriced and open sourced information that you can distill easily in a matter of 1-2 hours. The website itself from what I have seen doesn't have genuine listeners. Manipulated streams. Check reddit for more stories.

2026年9月9日
自発的なレビュー
Magicnothing ロゴ

Magicnothing からの回答

Zack here, founder of Magic Nothing.

We have no account or purchase matching this reviewer, and they didn't respond to Trustpilot's request for more information. So a couple of corrections for anyone reading:

1. Our courses are included with every account and have been since we moved them onto the platform, before this review was posted. They can't be overpriced because they don't have a price.

2. The listeners on our playlists are genuine. We run our own Meta Ads for our editorial playlists, and most of our curators run them for their own playlists. We also run bot detection on every playlist, pull streaming data straight from Spotify where we can, and remove curators who aren't acting in good faith. The removals are public and kept current at magicnothing.xyz/numbers.

If you've actually used the platform and had a bad experience, email us directly at info@magicnothing.com and we'll be happy to look into it with you :)

5つ星のうち1の評価

I have spent so much money on magic…

I have spent so much money on magic nothing to be on their playlist, however non seem to work and it came back with almost same feedback as if the same people are giving this feedbacks, and with the cost of submission, it’s really sad that I can’t get my songs on any of the playlists. I feel there is a level of partiality going on in this platform, as a new artist it’s impossible to get your song on their playlist. Other service works better, because they give good feedback and also accept new artists looking to grow their profile. I already stopped sending my songs.

2026年8月7日
自発的なレビュー
Magicnothing ロゴ

Magicnothing からの回答

Hey Melo, Zack here, I'm the founder of Magic Nothing. This is genuinely hard to read and I'm sorry you've had a rough experience.

To be straight with you about how Magic Nothing works, every submission gets a guaranteed listen/review and consideration from a curator, but we don't guarantee placement and curators are responsible for their own placement decisions and maintaining the quality of their playlists. Curators earn the same whether they accept or pass, so nobody makes an extra cent by rejecting you.

Each pass on a track comes with written feedback. I'd strongly suggest considering what's in that feedback, especially if there are patterns. If you do 10+ submissions, you can get a sense about what is or isn't resonating in your work. This is a huge (if not the biggest) value of honest curation. It's also the reason yes means anything.

I'd like to dig into your account with you personally and go through the feedback together. Email me at zack@magicnothing.com and I'll make the time.

Thanks so much for giving us a shot!

5つ星のうち3の評価

Not bad, could be better

I think this platform is artist-first, and I love that. I like that there are new options for playlists and discovery opportunities. However, it is extremely expensive and I usually get better results for what I’m paying on different platforms.

2026年6月25日
自発的なレビュー
Magicnothing ロゴ

Magicnothing からの回答

Hey Connor! Zack here, I'm the founder. Thanks for giving us a shot and glad to hear you found some new playlist and discovery opps. If you prefer lower price playlists, you can find them on our "browse playlists" page and filter by cost.

That said, prices on higher demand playlists and curators helps us hold them to a higher standard than other platforms because we pay them more for their time. Our hope is this leads to a better experience for artists and better curators on the platform, but we're always keeping an eye on things and working to improve so your honest feedback is helpful :)

Cheers,
-Zack

5つ星のうち5の評価

I really dig Magic Nothing

I've been a fan of Magic Nothing since the very beginning (well-targeted) instagram reels that quickly took off. I think what sets apart MN from other platforms is the trust I have in the brand. I have used SubmitHub for a little while now (for at least a year before MN) and I do think that platform is also really solid in terms of user experience. But knowing that MN is built from the ground up by artists, for artists, is a huge credibility boost for me. I trust the playlists that I am submitting to. I trust that their taste is solid and that, if I get declined, it's worth reflecting on the feedback.

I'm honestly impressed by how robust the platform itself is, considering it's been stood up by a super small team in a relatively short time—down to the email follow-ups and new features that pop up.

I think the ONE piece of feedback I have (it's picky, sorry i'm a designer haha) is that I wish each playlist had its own detail page. Maybe it's just me, but when I'm browsing playlists, I like to open each one in a tab and kinda narrow in on them after viewing a handful. I think it's hard to do that in a single list view with hundreds of curators. And in addition, I think a favorite/save button would be nice too.

2026年6月16日
自発的なレビュー
Magicnothing ロゴ

Magicnothing からの回答

This is excellent feedback, thank you Garet!

There actually is a playlist detail page but it's honestly kinda janky and hard to find (click "more" on the browse page under a playlist, then click "see full details"). I'd like to improve this when I get a chance.

And regarding your fav/save suggestion, I'm building this right now!! I've been wanting to add it forever and this review helped inspire it.

Thanks for sharing your experience and honest suggestions.

Zack

5つ星のうち5の評価

Magic nothing is such a great service

Magic nothing is such a great service! It’s so informative and lists how many people have saved the playlists you are submitting to, and I’ve had really good luck with them so far…once i submitted a song to a couple of of playlists that just weren’t quite the vibe but the curators told me why they rejected it and it gave me really good direction for where to submit next…and also Magic Nothing put it on a playlist themselves which was a really nice touch. Love these guys :)

2026年6月5日
自発的なレビュー
5つ星のうち3の評価

Their service definitely helped with…

Their service definitely helped with the visibility to a certain degree. I’ve used their service twice. Theres actual listeners vs bots , so that’s a plus , the only concerning thing is when you put the link of your track the website is recommending the same playlists and not every song will have the same vibe, so definitely check the playlist to be sure , cause it seems like once you pay for a playlist to be pitch to , you don’t get refunded or it gets rolled over to pitch to another playlist if were to be rejected by a specific playlist cause the vibe of your song doesn’t match what their looking for , but other than that the service is smooth nothing too complicated.

2026年5月15日
自発的なレビュー
Magicnothing ロゴ

Magicnothing からの回答

Zack here, founder of Magic Nothing.

Thanks for the feedback Ángel!

You have a great note in here about how the platform currently matches on an artist rather than a song (unfortunately, Spotify removed public API access to their song characteristics, so we can't use that data to inform our matching at the moment). The best approach to navigate this on our site is to select Similar Artists for each song and to think about which artists are the best representation for any song you're pitching.

Another move is to try the browse page, which allows you to filter for specific types of playlists (genre, keywords, performance, etc), but that takes a little more work up front.

Thanks again for trying out the platform and sharing your experience!

5つ星のうち5の評価

Pretty great platform to use

Pretty great platform to use. Great design, kind and responsive curators. Not the cheapest site, but honestly it ends up being worth it due to the quality of the experience. I’ve had good success finding playlists that are a good fit for my tunes.

2026年6月15日
自発的なレビュー
5つ星のうち5の評価

Magic Nothing Top Shelf Playlists

Although they charge more than Submithub and Submitlink, they seem to garner better playlists that genuinely do increase my Spotify streams when I submit a new release. I'm an Indie/Americana/Singer-Songwriter and appreciate the easy interface and kind folks who work for Magic Nothing. Highly recommend!

2026年3月24日
自発的なレビュー
5つ星のうち1の評価

Way too expensive for something you can get for 10% the cost at other historically established portals

For this price, I would recommend you stay away. There are better and more established options out there where you pay 10% of the cost and curators leave you feedback just like magicnothing. There is really nothing special this website offers except the extremely high costs. Paying someone 20 dollars to listen to a four minute or eight minute track. Thats more than minimum hourly wages in most of the Western World even. Would recommend against it until they really fix their pricing to match that of other portals or actually start offering something like ten times better than those portals.

2026年6月10日
自発的なレビュー
Magicnothing ロゴ

Magicnothing からの回答

Hey Pranav, Zack here, I run Magic Nothing.

I hear you on price, and it's an intentional call. We pay our curators well above what high-volume platforms pay, which lets us hold them to a real standard instead of competing in a race to the bottom. You're paying for genuine, thoughtful curation. No bots, no auto-declines, no pay-for-placement.

In your case all five playlists came back as passes, some with detailed notes on the track. I know that stings -- I'm an artist too and I've been on the receiving end of it plenty -- but that's curators being honest instead of rubber-stamping. My honest take is it's useful signal on where the song isn't landing yet, and a different song or different playlists next time can tell you a lot.

We reached out by email to follow up but didn't hear back. That offer still stands. Reply to that thread or email me directly at zack@magicnothing.com and I'll handle it personally.

Thanks for giving us a shot!
Zack

5つ星のうち5の評価

Magic nothing is the real deal

Magic nothing is such an invaluable platform and some of the best money I have ever spent! After getting on just a few of their playlists, my monthly listeners skyrocketed, my streams quadrupled, and I even got in touch with my manager! Thank you Magic Nothing 🙏- Travis Seal

2026年6月8日
自発的なレビュー
5つ星のうち5の評価

Satisfied

It’s so satisfying seeing my artist project streams going up! I know that they are real people and it comforts me. The whole team is very professional. As long as you have good music to begin with, you can expect good results with magic nothing.

2026年6月4日
自発的なレビュー
5つ星のうち5の評価

I love Magic Nothing!

I discovered Magic Nothing recently and ran a few song campaigns through them! I was so impressed by the results of the campaigns, and my music was being steamed by real people on real playlists. So grateful to have found this and will keep using as part of my release strategies!

2026年5月28日
自発的なレビュー
Magicnothing ロゴ

Magicnothing からの回答

thanks for the note Lexi!! we're glad you found the platform helpful and appreciate you giving it a shot :)
-Zack

5つ星のうち5の評価

magic nothing is a gem!

I am a indie/alternative pop musician. My manager told me about magic nothing. It's a gem!
The platform is easy to use and I got added to some playlists that are getting me streams.
So glad that I found it!

2026年5月26日
自発的なレビュー
Magicnothing ロゴ

Magicnothing からの回答

i love this Annie! thanks so much for sharing your music and your feedback. sounds like your manager is a gem too ;)

-Zack

5つ星のうち5の評価

Love Magic Nothing

Love Magic Nothing! A kind and supportive team, I’ve had great results from their playlists.

2026年5月22日
自発的なレビュー
Magicnothing ロゴ

Magicnothing からの回答

thanks Marielle! we appreciate you and we care about our work very much
-Zack

Trustpilot エクスペリエンス

Trsutpilot のレビューは誰でも書くことができます。レビューを書いた人には自分の書いたレビューをいつでも編集したり削除したりする権限があり、それらのレビューはアカウントがアクティブである限り表示されます。

プラットフォーム保護のため、専門チームと高度なテクノロジーを駆使しています。偽レビューとの闘いについての詳細はこちらをご一読ください。

Trustpilot におけるレビュー プロセスの詳細についてはこちらをご覧ください。

よいレビューを書くための8つのヒントをご覧ください。

確認を行うことで、Trustpilot に投稿されるレビューが [LINK-BEGIN-PEOPLE]実在の人物[LINK-END-PEOPLE] によって書かれたものであることの保証につながります。

レビューに対してインセンティブを提供したり、選択的にレビューを依頼したりすることは、TrustScore にバイアスを生む可能性があります。これは 当社のガイドラインに反します。

詳細情報