Tradephantoms レビュー 190

I stayed with Trade Phantoms for about three months, so this is coming from actual experience, not a quick judgment.

To be fair, their technical analysis methodology, especially their approach to institutional order flow and supply/demand charting, is legitimately valuable. I did walk away with a better understanding of how to read price action, and for that, I give them credit.

However, the main issue, and the reason I’m leaving, is the lack of professionalism during paid sessions. In Mr. Green’s FOREX classes, a significant portion of the time is spent on personal rants about politics and religion. These topics are highly divisive, and they consistently pull focus away from what members are actually paying for: improving their trading skills.

I paid $140/month for structured, trading-focused education. Instead, too many sessions drifted into commentary about political views, criticism of leadership, opinions on international conflicts, and religious perspectives. Regardless of where anyone stands on those issues, that’s not appropriate for a paid trading class. It creates an uncomfortable environment and dilutes the value of the education. All news moves markets up and down it doesn’t need opinion, someone’s opinion is irrelevant.

What makes this harder to justify is that Mr. Black provides free live sessions regularly. If you’re considering joining, you’re honestly better off taking advantage of those free resources rather than paying for sessions that often go off-topic.

Bottom line: there is real value in their technical approach, but the paid experience is inconsistent and frequently sidetracked by personal opinions that don’t belong in a professional learning environment. I came to get better at trading, not to sit through unrelated commentary.

Because of that, I can’t recommend the paid membership. I give one star because zero stars was not available.

If want to learn to trade the right way with proper structure and discipline this is the coarse for you they treat this with respect like any business should best thing I ever did

Tradephantoms offer an excellent educational system , support and mentors.

If you want to be mentored by professionals, understand the market structure and trade forex , futures and options ...phantoms are the real deal.

I get why some people have some feelings about mr green "the forex master" he is a straight forward man if he didn't like your attitude he'll just speak up which is a good thing people you got a transparent mentor but it's not for everyone ,i get it some people are soft.

Last thing i wanna say you can't be soft and a trader these two things don't mix so man up and come join the phantoms.

These guys are the real deal. I started with Tradephantoms as a complete beginner and am wildly impressed with how much I have learned. I've completed their essentials and forex courses and am now taking futures and thought I would share a few reasons why I recommend them:

- Coursework is well structured and easy to follow.
- Exclusive live sessions multiple times a week to see exactly how the pros trade.
- All classes/live sessions that you sign up for are saved and can be re-watch if missed.
- Access to great community of enthusiastic traders to bounce ideas off of.
- Mr. Green, Mr. Blue, and Mr. Black each bring distinct personalities and trading styles, creating a more well-rounded and diverse mentorship experience.

If you are new to trading, I would recommend starting with Forex after completing Essentials. You will gain a better understanding of how different currencies and markets interact with each other while learning to trade on a slower moving asset class.

I joined trade phantoms for 3 reasons. 1) Price is very affordable compared to other trading groups.
2) With trade phantoms you can learn how to trade crypto, forex, futures and options. They offer classes and live trading sessions.
3) They offer, a community where among the students themselves help each other. They also have a support group where you can submit your homework and any problem you have they always answer you as soon as possible.
Mr. Black, Mr. Blue and Mr. Green the instructors are very knowledgable and are very passionate when they teach us. I would recommend them without a doubt to anyone who wants to learn about trading.

Hands down the best education on learning how to really trade with the banks, I will forever be grateful I found you guys

I joined this community (and it is truly a community) several months ago. In addition to the multiple asset training classes and live trading sessions, there are multiple WhatsApp chats that I'm part of, I have learned so much from Mr. Black, Mr. Green and my fellow Phantoms.

I currently only have experience with Mr. Black, who taught me the essentials, and I watch daily on TikTok for his chart analysis, and Mr. Green, who is currently teaching me all there is to know about Forex. Once I get more comfortable with Forex, I will move onto other assets classes with Mr. Blue (I have sat in on his live trading sessions, and he definitely knows his stuff). I've found this truly is a scenario where you get back what you put in. If you're not putting in the work, you will definitely struggle (I'm guilty of this). But if you're willing to show up, they are there to teach and guide you.

I look forward to sessions with Mr. Green. I participate in his twice a week live trading and multiple Forex classes (I have taken Forex Focus and Advanced Forex multiple times and I learn something new each time...you can take the classes as many times as you'd like). My biggest obstacle is confidence. Mr. Green's energy, and knowledge, is giving me the confidence that I can do this and be successful. I'm so happy I made the decision to stay and watch Mr. Black's live on TikTok back in November!!

I have been investing and trading for 25 years. This company has updated my trading ability in a huge way. They are more conservative than I am which acts as an excellent balance foe me in such a turbulent market. I would highly recommend this strategy for traders of all levels who want exposure to the markets. They do cover stocks, options, futures, forex and crypto. I am very happy that I did so much research and found this team!

I’m very proud to be a member of TPs. All the staff members are kind, sharp, passionate, and most professional. Mr. Green is no exception - quite the contrary, he’s profoundly passionate about pedagogy, the art of “the trade”, psychology, and FX!

Tradephantoms is a dynamic and supportive community with instructors—Blue, Black, and Green—covering nearly every major trading strategy, including swings, options, forex, and futures. If you’re looking for an instructor who is genuinely invested in your growth, Mr. Green is the one you want in your corner.
With his great sense of humor and clear teaching style, he makes even the most complex concepts approachable. I never miss an opportunity to attend his Forex sessions. What truly sets him apart is his honesty—he keeps it real. He emphasizes that success takes effort while consistently going the extra mile to ensure you understand every factor influencing a trade.
More than just an instructor, Mr. Green is deeply committed to his students’ confidence and long-term success. He encourages independent thinking, explains concepts with clarity, and genuinely wants to see his students win.

Thank you for all you do Mr. Black, Mr. Green and of course Mr. Blue!!!

Trade Phantoms teaches options, futures and forex at a high level. I’ve been a member of 3 different trading education groups and this one is by far the most advanced and professional.
Mr Green and Mr Blue are totally different educators/traders but both are highly experienced and professional. Green is known for holding us accountable and calling us out for stupid actions. I love this approach. Very personal attention.

The phantoms offers a well structured trading system on multiple asset classes. You first get to learn what institutional order flow is , and how to gauge it in the markets / score the markets (essentials from Mr. Black )Mr. Black does a great job explaining the basics of trading and how to use proper risk management. From there you get to to choose for 3 different asset classes Forex ( Taught by Mr. Green) Futures/Options (Taught by Mr .blue ) . I personally prefer the forex asset classes the teacher (Mr. Green) teaches how to use fundamentals ( how to trade the news ) and technicals( institutional order flow) his personality makes learning from him easy to flow and trading less stressful. I do recommend taking Futures/Options if you like more action. The teacher ( Mr. Blue) offers a lot of knowledge on how to find liquidity and a more in depth explanation on institutional order flow ( moving averages and vwaps). Since his class does offers more action he tends to move very fast but once you get to understand him there is no Turning back. They also offer a good support system so if you have any questions email them and they will respond relatively quickly.

Trade phantoms is the best thing I’ve ever came across, I was so lost in trading trying to use the 3 letter people on YouTube but then finally realising that no professionals trade that way. So I joined phantoms and everything changed, I had my 1-1 with mr green and he advised me and a proper trade plan and trading suddenly got a whole lot easier because I have a proper strategy, I stick to rules and I follow RISK. All thanks to mr black, blue, green and Tom. These guys go above and beyond for everyone in that group. Thank you

I never truly understood how the market worked until I joined Trade Phantoms. Their explanations are clear, structured, and easy to apply. Since joining, my entire trading journey has transformed. Trade Phantoms has been the best decision I’ve made—they really know how to guide you.

Everything from the structure of the information to the mentors and instructors is nothing short of impressive. Every single person, including the support team, makes it incredibly easy to feel right at home.

One thing to understand is that the value you get is directly tied to the effort you put in. This is important. Like the gym, a job, or any meaningful pursuit, you have to approach it with respect and consistency.

TradePhantoms is more than excellent. The instructors, especially Mr. Green, bring a wealth of knowledge and a personality that genuinely fosters a strong sense of community. He tells it like it is haha, but honestly, that kind of honesty is something we all need at times.

Mr. Blue brings a level of passion and energy that is hard to match, while Mr. Black stands out for his strong fundamentals, professionalism, and clear understanding of IOF. Together, they create a well-rounded and supportive learning environment.

Overall, it is an experience that truly rewards the effort you put into it.

Trade Phantoms offers a well-structured program with clear, accurate training on trading various asset classes. I’ve been part of the Forex group with Mr. Green and have been very happy with the experience and results. His classes are engaging, honest, and conducted in a safe, open-minded environment. I intend to continue with the group for the foreseeable future and recommend it to serious traders..

What a great system they have put together here at Tradephantoms. The ability to retake each class as often as you need to is invaluable. Instructors are all awesome and helpful. I’ve been focusing on Forex with Mr Green. At first I didn’t think Forex was my thing but I love Mr Greens classes and live sessions and it has really grown on me. Thank you Tradephantoms!

The best decision in my trading journey was to join the Phantoms, I had blown many accounts before, but as soon as i started learning with them i have improved bigtime, I benefited mostly from Mr. Greens Psychology classes they're ownsome, not to forget his Forex classes, and the live trading session are priceless. Essentials with Mr.Black made me see charts in a deferent way, i remember something he said ''Once you see it, you can never unsee it'', Mr.Blue is on another level simply the best.

TradePhantoms has great instructors breaking the charts down from high to lower time frame's and defining candlesticks. Mr.Black, Mr.Green and Mr.Blue having a common denominator with a different view is great for all as people interpret differently, they move visions into a reality.

I have been a Phantom for 8 months Mr Green has been my instructor the whole time. My trading and attitude towards the market couldn’t be more on spot! Thanks to the team they have been outstanding! Highly recommended!