Brookstradingcourse レビュー 7

The presenters are ungrateful for us paying them $4 a day. They believe they are doing us a favor by “teaching” us. I learn much more when I get off the webinars. They ramble on and on. Not very helpful and they pretend it’s helpful, especially Rose. I just want to shut down the computer when she talks. This lady rambles on purpose so we can pay her without saying much.

Al brooks also has a person named “Jed” marking up the chart. I trade longer than her and I see she is obviously don’t know how to trade well . I follow her in the trade room and she definitely doesn’t know her stuff. She started trading 20 months ago. A real joke. Rose is a nasty, narcissistic person and everyone in her traderoom knows that. All the real traders pretty much left the traderoom. Unless you have no concience, you stay. I’m pretty much done with Al brooks. This is too dishonest. This is such a joke business to the education world. The teaching is vague and unhelpful a lot of times. When you give them feedback, they will ban you.

Also, if they get a new person to write their blog without checking PnL, you really have to question Richard and Al Brooks. Are they good traders? They made the course but that doesn’t mean they are good traders. If they make a lot of money in trading, why do they need a teaching business? It makes no sense.

I joined the room for a couple of months. Rose doesn’t even trade pure price action — in fact, a lot of what she teaches goes against what AL Brooks talks about. Brooks barely gives importance to Fibonacci levels, while Rose heavily relies on them, so I honestly don’t even understand why she’s positioned there as a price action mentor.

And one more thing — don’t even think about asking presenters for a verified PNL. People get banned instantly for that without even being given a fair chance to explain themselves.

I was hoping to see price action theory applied in real-time, but my experience was incredibly disappointing. Instead of providing a clear directional bias, The presenter is hostile and provides ambiguity. She tends to talk nonstop about both sides of the trade, only to act like she told you the correct direction after the fact.

There is no live execution to learn from, as she would only state her trades after the price action had already started moving in her direction. It felt completely reliant on hindsight rather than actual real-time trading.

To make matters worse, the room is not welcoming to beginners. When "newbies" ask questions, Rose is dismissive, often telling them to just "go watch the course" or using arbitrary rules to threaten them with bans. If you are looking for actual mentorship, be warned: she has explicitly stated in private messages that the trading room is not a classroom and that they are not teachers. Save your $99 a month if you are actually looking for live, transparent trade execution and a supportive learning environment.

This is a review of the trading group, which is sadly a waste of time and money. Presenters sound very convincing and professional, but when you listen closely, they are constantly misleading the audience. E.g. the presenter is very bearish at the bottom of the trading range. Talks about selling for 15 minutes and then voila, says "ok, I am closing my long, this is great".

The US session always has two consecutive presenters who very often completely contradict each other. There is arguably 1 presenter who will get you into trades (or help you stay out of bad ones).

I have transcribed all the recordings, so I've got the receipts if anyone is interested.

Occasionally, the stream is good, but the inconsistency does not make this a practical tool for anyone serious about trading. If you want entertainment, sure, at least all the presenters are really civilised, and I bet they're nice people irl.

This was the trading education I was hoping for. Have only been a member for a month now but everybody has been really great

Impossible to log on.
Dated infrastructure & technology not fit for purpose.

I was about to sign up for a 6 week $2,500 course then stumbled upon Brooks Trading Course for only $399 with over a hundred hours of content (6x more than the $2,500 course). I was very impressed with Brooks Trading Course, it was a very good and thorough when breaking down price action, with a lot of information, all for like 1/6th the price of most other course’s out there, I feel like it helped me understand price action a lot more than before and it helped me see the markets clearly. I would highly recommend this course to anyone looking to get in trading or for even seasoned traders who need to sharpen their edge in the markets. Only advice I’d say is definitely take your time watching the videos, and don’t try to rush through it.