Mater Private Hospital レビュー 

Mater Hospital Dublin’s catering is excellent.

There’s a particular catering staff called Alina who served me food and she was excellent, an amazing staff.

Had to go to Mater private in Dublin last Wednesday 23rd Nov from Limerick, my appointment was for 11am for my procedure, however this was not carried out until 3pm, there was also to be a follow up telephone call the following day which never happened, however I have to say that the nurses and doctors could not be nicer, it's a pity about the admin side of the hospital, which I was told on the day was the cause for the delay.

Horrendous woman on the public hospital information desk, asked her politely for directions to the private hospital to be snapped at and told she was “sick of giving directions all day” - even though she was working at a desk clearly marked INFORMATION, and I would assume helping people is part of her job. Terrible choice of person to have welcome you in or help you should you need anything in a huge hospital which is very poorly laid out.

Amazing experience all the staff on the cardiac ward make you feel so safe and at home trust me when I say they will look after you, thank you all of you for making my stay that little bit easier.
Christine Rolando jan stuti jasmin and the rest I cannot think of there names amazing

I would just like to say a big thank you to all the level 3 mc givney wing staff and the cardiology department yous were all so lovely and caring for me today so big thank you keep up your great work

My husband got a surgery 6 months ago ( the doctor “ hace good profile “ I don’t thinks so … after the surgery He never check my husband … days later my husband feels bad again and He called to the hospital to try to get an appointment with the same doctor who made the surgery but surprise he never appeared.
Last week my husband went by emergency because the pain was really bad, they got 5 tube blood test and have been talking with the “ doctor” as well waiting for the scan and surprise 4 days later We are still waiting for a call for next appointment to check results and do new surgery … they just sent him painkillers…
I wondering any other “ Doctor “ can check him ? Are you waiting he dies ? Come on how long as doctor you have to study ? 5-7 years ! So are very slow in get a reaction ……

Very bad knowledge and practice about medicine !

I have read these reviews and I must have been in a different hospital cause I think the mater is excellent appointment at 10 and was receiving treatment at 11 . I was constantly ask if I was OK through the hole day thank you doctor memon. Also 1 staff member drove me to the shop in the morning. I couldn't have had a better experience
Thank you to all at the mater

Surgery on 7th April went well but this place has no customer service ethic. I was admitted at 8am. I Sat in a corridor until I said I was going home at 3. 30. I was then taken to a 4 bed ward and had surgery about 6pm. I tested positive on 8th and 9th for Covid but no one told me. I was sent home with it on 11th and encouraged to stop for lunch en route. Later I got a text to say I was positive after blowing out candles on a birthday cake
And sharing it when I got home. While a patient no toilet paper was provided for a whole day and it was difficult to get a jug of water. I could go on and on. My review direct to the Mater Private was not acknowledged. This cost me a lot of money!!

It is virtually impossible to get someone to answer the ward phone . This is no fault of the nurses who do a terrific job under very busy conditions but communication needs to be reviewed.

My daughter has had bowel problems and we decided to go private to get the best advice and sort this out once and for all.We waited months for a colonoscopy and endoscopy and after 5 weeks still no word, after multiple phone messages (they don't answer the phone) from us and our GP still no word. A colleagues child got a consultation the same day as her colonoscopy in the General in Tralee recently. We have just been admitted to the Bons Secours for the same procedures with hopefully with answers.

I am going to write a reactive review from 2015/2016. My experience was with Dr Carney. Who I felt is one of the most arrogant person imaginable. I was a mild 35 year old with my dad on his deathbed. He had no compassion, no understanding. Everyone around me would say but his child had a disability so probably bringing his tempter to work. No excuse!. When I entered his office from a flight from the UK, I had some questions and hopeful solutions, but once I opened my mouth, All I could hear from Dr Carey was "who is this that graces my carpet". I mean really what era are we working in?
Don't get me wrong my dad was difficult and probably knew more than Doctors as he was a senior vet (both biological fields). My dad chose Dr Carney on the basis that his cousin (Dr Naughton) was a senior doctor and recommend him as very good. Dr Carney maybe very good but absolutely terrible at talking to people which if front line is as important as being a good doctor. I do wonder if anyone else had similar issue with Dr Carney as I would like him struck off! I can't imagine that my dad got up the nose of Dr Carney that this was an isolated case.

To access to emergency department you need an appointment.

My stomach is unable to process most foods on this earth. I get severe nausea and bad headaches in relation to foods. This was proven at the Beaumont migraine clinic. Waited many months to be contacted by a Mater Gastroenterologist. I get a call in August. It’s a junior doctor. He asks loads of questions. Then he says he will book me in for gastroscopy and dietician in November. I get a letter. It advises A delay. Anyway the gastroscopy is eventually completed. I am to see a gastroenterologist as a follow up and feedback. He asks all the same questions again. Then he says the results are negative. He also says the results of a much earlier endoscope investigation of my lower bowel were also negative, so there is nothing they can do. It’s like thank you and goodbye. i reply that there is definitely something wrong with my digestion because some problem between my stomach and large intestine is poisoning my body. He calls the senior gastroenterologist. They come back and I get the same story. Basically I am blocked. They refused to check further. i asked what about food samples from my gut. What about stool tests. Could they work with other specialists? They said they had completed their work which was check my gastro intestinal tract end to end with a camera. No more. In the end they told me there was nothing more they could do and I need to go back to my GP. Whatever happened to doctors and specialist who work together to IDENTIFY AND RESOLVE a problem. Sorry but the quality of the gastro department at Mater is unbelievably low. I am not mentioning names just the unit and the hospital. I really feel the department functions like a bunch of medical camera operators who have no wider knowledge or the will to discover the underlying problem. I waited one year and I am no better. In fact if this progresses further I will have to live on a drip! But they do not care!

The short version

The hospital is slow, expensive, and inefficient.

The Kafkaesque

1- I made an appointment made through a third-party app, which is set and implemented by either you directly as a company or your staff, so definitely that's not an excuse for delay.
I didn't come in begging for a last-minute appointment, I picked a 5 pm appointment, one out of several time slots available on that date.

2- On the app there's no clear reference to the fact that the appointment would have been in a hospital, which is always a slow and burdensome process compared to a private studio and having known in advance, I would have probably avoided it.

3- On the app the price was advertised at €90, while I was charged €139.

4- The next day I get notified via mail that I received texts from the doctor over the app which is downloadable only through an Italian app store, which I cannot access, so I have no idea what the doctor is trying to communicate...
There's no phone number, no e-mail on the app, and looking up the doctor, nothing still...

5- I finally receive a call from the hospital which has both my email and phone number to confirm my appointment at 19:00.
I then double-check, whether I made a mistake, but the appointment was definitely booked at 17:00, as confirmed via mail, which I communicate to the attendant.

6- The hospital calls me back one more time, confirming the appointment at 16:45. I ask indications on where to park, as these are big structures, and I get told, "Just come around and we'll tell you."

7- At 16:15 I get to the hospital, follow google maps diligently and find myself stuck at the back, at the first aid entrance, so I go back one km or so, turn around and get to the front entrance. (You might want to fix your location on Google Maps)

7- I finally get in, now, one queue after the other, filling in the same information over and over again, get charged well above advertised price, and then being told I should have shown up 1 HOUR IN ADVANCE!!
(Yes, because that's how slow their admission is, I would have appreciated having known that before, along with the parking info thanks).

8- I finally get to the right section of the hospital, it's now 17:00, I think I'm late, having spent half an hour in admission (Where there were maybe 12 people waiting and 12 "working" -_- ) I get asked for my name, which... Is not on the list...

9- The nurses figure I must have been switched with someone else, and my appointment is... At 17:00...

10- It's 17:45 when I finally head downstairs to get a refund.

11- Where I wait in line for another 10 minutes, while a few people in admission go in before me, because apparently if you get a refund you can get 3 numbers over the next one in line, because who cares...

12- Finally the clerk calls the number before mine, there's nobody, apart from me (as the number still has to be issued), asks me my number, and with a confused look on his face, ( I arrived before the other 3 people who got served before me), asks me to go to the counter.

13- I get my money back, I go home

THE END...

Was contacted by the Belfast trust and offered default contract operation for kidney disease at Mater Private Hospital that was overdue by 4 years and was suffering daily with weekly visit to hospital. The consultant Mr Nick Hegarty and staff treaty myself and family with the upmost respect. The hospital staff were very pleasant and helpful (especially Staff nurse Tara in pre op) and the team in the ward. The operation was successful and give me a better future with my family and friends. I would therefore recommend the Mater Private Hospital in Dublin.

Cherrywood Day hospital amazing, I rang up and spoke about getting a test that I needed for cardiac screening and they were able to fit me in the following morning. Everyone was so helpful and generous, very good experience and would recommend them for your care!

I had an appointment with Dr. Paul Kiely consultant, in relation to a spine problem. The appointment was for 12:00, I arrived early and was asked to take a seat. By 12:45 I was still waiting and in some discomfort after sitting in an un comfortable chair for 45 minutes. I asked if the appointment was going ahead and the secretary with a South African accent told me there was a "slight delay" and would I mind waiting. By 1pm, after waiting for over an hour I informer the secretary I was leaving. No apology was offered for the 1 hour delay. I don't mind paying any amount for a service, but I could believe the appalling service from Dr. Kiely. If you have an appointment with him, bring a packed lunch.

Greg Cunningham

Mater Private Hospital is a money making machine which basically squeeze the patients and get all the money of our them they can, and use excuses of external consultants to take themselves away from responsibility.

When consultants are requested to provide medical reports to justify tests and visits, they deny.

When you contact their quality department, they say "the person doesnt work for us" with an attempt to play technicalities of private consultancy... Let alone that all consultants sign letters and invoice as Mater Private.

They request multiple tests and visits unnecessarily just cash in more money and not caring how much pain and distress they put their patients in.

An absolute cruel way to deal with people's health and finances...

BEWARE