ERT Signals レビュー 52

I normally don’t write reviews, but this experience genuinely frustrated me and hundreds of other clients enough to put it all down publicly. If you’re thinking about joining, slow down and really think it through first, because what me and about 320 clients experienced was nothing like what’s advertised.

From the beginning, the whole setup is heavily focused on getting people through the door rather than actually delivering consistent results. The onboarding process immediately raises concerns especially being told to open and close positions just to “verify” the account where you literally lose money before even copying a signal. Thats required by the broker or old mate Basil & Herb doesn't get paid is CPA from the broker. That was the first moment I started questioning whether the priorities were where they should be.

What disgusted me was the actual performance versus what’s promoted. There were periods of small wins, sure — but they often felt insignificant compared to the losses that followed. It constantly felt like you could spend weeks slowly building gains, only to watch them disappear in one or two trades. That cycle repeated enough times that it stopped feeling like bad luck and started feeling like poor risk management.

He takes profit on XAUUSD trades at 10-20 pips and his stop loss is 100-150 pips

Winning at 83% means nothing if you trade with a 1:0.10 risk vs reward

The emotional toll is something I don’t think gets talked about enough. Watching your balance slowly climb and then suddenly drop in a short period of time is exhausting and i personally lost over $200,000 following his signals. Oh yeah his "unregulated broker" also apparentally offers you a deposit bonus, which is just another way for you to lose your money twice as fast as the bonus literally does nothing other than increase your risk by 2x.

This guy is the epitome of a scammer and has made millions on the back of hard working people losing all their money. Karma is a real thing Basil & Herb and you have something coming for what you're doing.

I speak for the thousands of people that have been scammed by your fake ass service and we are building a class-action against you to get you shut down.

One of my favourite things that he does. He says to enter a position and it loses -100 pips. But then he instantly enters another position and it wins +10 pips. You're still down -90 pips across both trades but he has the audacity to tell you what a crazy day of profits team and starts forwarding fake-ass screenshots of profit to the free community to create fomo as he plays on peoples emotions.

Oh yeah another thing. You cant talk to other clients. Its a straight up scam. Basil boy why cant we talk and communicate with other people? ahh yes. Because you know what would happen then. The chat would be filled with threats and pissed off people losing their shit with you like they do when they dm you 1 on 1.

In the end, karma always comes around for people like this and you can't run away for ever. The main claims he believes in god aswell. What a joke of a human

If you’re thinking about handing your hard-earned cash over to Basil Atwani and his so-called “Elite Reality Trading,” do yourself a favor and run the other way. This isn’t trading education or signals – it’s a straight-up con designed to line Basil’s pockets while you bleed money. He profits big time from affiliates and commissions every time suckers like you sign up, deposit, and inevitably lose it all on his garbage “advice.” Newsflash: Basil doesn’t know jack about trading. He’s just a smooth-talking fraudster peddling illusions of wealth.
He brags about some mythical 80% win rate? Pure BS. The few wins get obliterated by massive losses that wipe out any gains – that’s if his trades even hit that mark, which they don’t. Why do you think comments are disabled on his Telegram channels? Because real users would expose the dumpster fire for what it is: a parade of blown accounts and broken dreams. No accountability, no discussion, just Basil ghosting while counting your referral fees.
And those glowing 5-star reviews plastered everywhere? Fake as hell. Bought and paid for, probably from the same bot farms he uses to hype his “elite” nonsense. Don’t fall for the smoke and mirrors – this guy’s empire is built on your losses. Save your money, learn from legit sources, and tell Basil Atwani to shove his scam where the sun doesn’t shine. Zero stars, utter fraud.

I followed ERT Signals over the recent weeks and my experience was negative overall.

Most trades did not reach their full take profit targets. In many cases, only a small portion of the move was captured (roughly 10–15% of the intended take profit), and trades were closed before the full target was achieved.

However, when a trade hit stop loss, the loss was disproportionately large. The end result was that after weeks of taking trades and building small gains, a single losing trade wiped out the progress and pushed the account into negative territory.

In my view, the risk/reward profile and trade management were not suitable, and the performance did not meet expectations.

One additional concern: I have also seen members being encouraged to leave positive reviews in exchange for incentives/rewards (for example, prizes or cash rewards for the “best” reviews). If reviews are incentivised, it may impact how representative the overall rating appears.

I’m sharing this as my personal experience so others can make an informed decision and apply strict risk management if they choose to follow these signals.

Scam. Inflates his 10pip win streaks all for 1 loss to tank 2-3weeks of earnings, He was decent until he launched his own funded now he tanks your funded accounts on purpose so people buy more. Don't be fooled. I recommend Nate fx or Callisto actual traders with explanation

Don’t recommend him. He’s a scammer

Not very happy with as I subscribed back with them back in 2024 under fxcess. Around a month a go I broke my phone and when I finally got back into telegram my accounts where gone so I asked Basil if I could get back into the group he said for me to send my account number that I signed up with so I showed him my fxcess account but he said we don’t use that anymore you will have to sign up to our new broker to get back in witch I think is very unfear as I was already a member he just wants the extra commissions from the new sign up

Absolutely awful experience. I know little about trading, but I know that whatever this is, it's not sustainable! I've copied from 25th May to 25th June, and im at a 20% loss of my investment. I should also point out, that this is at half the lot size that this guy recommended. If I'd done things his way, I'd be at a 40% loss in 30 days. The explanation as to why this is not sustainable is because you can't keep taking heavy losses and then only making small profits to cover for those loses! It needs to be the other way around. Anyone copying is just hemorrhaging money. Oh but not the trader of course, his losses are covered by the commission he's making commision from everyone (yes, even on losing trades). We lose, we lose. He loses, he doesn't.

What makes this so shady is the following: He gets you to do a test trade at a ridiculous lot size for no reason, and you end up losing a lot of money, while he gets commision. There could be a day (actually there are many days) when you lose thousands in 2 or 3 trades, and then make a couple of hundred back in a final trade. He'll actually congratulate that and say 'let's see your profits'. What profit? Do the maths. There is no profit! What a slap in the face. Of course, there's a reason behind this. Gullible folk will send him screenshots of those wins so that he can post them in groups where people are yet to sign up! The small wins are because he closes winning trades early, and yet he has the nerve to say 'full target smashed' although he didn't wait for the full target to be smashed - 'full target smashed' seems to be a regular occurrence on losing trades though. The ridiculous thing about all of this is, if I did the opposite of what he said in the 30 days I copied, i.e buy instead of sell, and sell instead of buy, I would be in healthy profit right now. Ha. It's a free service of course and he's just doing this to help everyone, always forgets to mention the commision he gets out of everyone though. Nothing is free! Also, let's talk about the deposit bonus. It means nothing, because it uses your money first. And once your money is gone, there's not much chance of getting it back with the bonus if the strategy has lost you all yours in the first place. The most scandalous thing about all of this is that he has a well known youtube influencer in on this too - Josef Rakic. Someone I actually admired. These 2 flash their cash and their cars online, tell you that you can leave ur 9-5 job, post up screenshots of huge wins (a lot of the time from 2024), and they do all of this on massive losing days. More slaps in the face of those struggling to get by in life. I've also looked at some of these screenshots and they show multiple different trades at various times of the day. When you cross reference this with the telegram group, you see that their were only 2 trades sent out that day. It's just red flag after red flag. Oh yeah, have a look at all the positive comments. Funny how they are regularly made on the same date. I'm probably going to be homeless in a couple of weeks. Not that these guys care. It's just rinse and repeat for them.

Basil is a machine ! No one plays the game like this man.

This is my personal experience doing copy trading with ERT Signals. If you are successful from this then good for you, but this is just based on what I've experienced these past 5 weeks.

Can you make profit here? You definitely can. My issue is the amount of profit being made does not make up for the high losses. In fact, I've come into ERT Signals with an overall loss rather than making any profit, which isn't what I expected when joining. I will admit the process of copying trades is fairly straight forward and easy to understand, I just think the decisions being made are extremely risky.

For example, there was a day when the group made 3 losses, and submitted a 4th entry. When the entry finally was in profit margin, people in the group were still told not to close. It wasn't until the group suffered a heavy loss again that it was decided to close. Yes, I could've closed the trade on my own without needing to follow the team when it was in the profits, but again we are copy trading these professionals for a reason. They do have their own disclosed strategy which I can respect, but it's this risky behaviour that has me losing trust in these signals.

Keep in mind these professionals have tonnes of money to play with and can brush off these losses fairly fine. I am assuming many of you are like me, who are looking to make extra income but do not have the funds to risk losing, especially as a student.

I will agree with some earlier reviews that a lot of the reviews published here are from users with the incentive given from the team that leaving a 5-star review will offer them some credit to use in their trading. Unfortunately with the use of Telegram, it is impossible for me to communicate with other people in the VIP group to know their experiences. I will say I found it interesting that there were over 20,000 people in the ERT Group but only just over 2,000 in the VIP group.

Again, there are people who make profits in the group. Whenever there are wins, the team floods the chat with screenshots of people winning. However it's only the wins you see as for obvious reasons the team does not want to share losses from their copiers and I'm sure there are plenty that are upset.

Hope this review is useful to anyone researching into these signals

I lost all of my money following ERT. i´m following him since three weeks and all of my mone is gone. Beware he offering to win money at the community by writing 5 star reviews.His Risk Reward Ratio is horrible he risking about 500-1000 Pips gaining only 70 Pips.thats a RR of 3:1 and not the recommended 1:3 RR.Yes yu make money but the winning are so small and the Stoplosses are very high. He also don´t put a Takeprofit and says manually when to close and with that you kinda gambeling.There was one big loss with 1000 pips and he lied in the analysis it was only 70 pips. Don´t fall for signal groups i tried a few and all where scam and they making money through the affiliate with the broker. he also says in the beginning to change the Lotsize from 0.01 to 1,00 and open a trade and let it run for 5 minutes to see if evereything works and don´t fall for that this is a trap too and he making money with that specific step and you losing money he fooling beginners. Sad that so many people out there selling this scam signals with no conscience to take out the money out the pocket from the people that don´t have this much money. In the end little wins and huge Stoplosses don´t recommend this Signal Sercive

ERT Signals is by far hands down the best signals forex channel out there , Mr Basil is a no nonsense guy who is thee utmost honest up front mentor , I wish I hadn't sat on the fence for so long , there accuracy on the signals has been spot on and currently on a 6 week 100% hit take profit roll , awesome team and leader , Mr Basil 👍 you da man brother 😁😎

I'm not really into writing reviews but Basil and the team are absolutely killing it. I have been with them for a couple of months and the accuracy of the trades they send out is remarkable. They always get back to you when you have questions. To be honest I cant really fault them. My advice- give them a try , you wont be sorry. At the moment its still free to join

I have been amongst Basil and his team for 1 week now & I can definitely say this “he is a man of his word” and he delivers. I highly recommend him & his team.

HikzFx

Trade are effortless. Financially free, got a new car and house from these signals. Started with a mere $300.

Would highly recommend if you have no trading experience,

Full blown newbie to trading and Basil is super helpful and explains everything to a tee 🥰 learning loads and his win streak is wilddddd!!!!

Leticia

Being a complete novice in trading i was really nervous in joining Basil's VIP community. Only few days in and already beaming with confidence. The team has made the journey easy to follow for beginners, they get you trading super quickly with no fuss. (935542)

This team and basil are fantastic!! It’s a process that takes time to learn, and an 80%+ win rate is amazing and currently the group is 21/21! And beginning a five week run!! Hard efforts pay off

So unsure about if I join or not to this telegram group, to this community and being honest it’s been the best and profitable months, so far!

My trading experience have been nothing short of exceptional. Great signals, great service and timeous payouts.

Bullwaves: 931448

Amazing signals, the help provided to setup is second to non,All profits so far, excited to be part of this group

930028